Olly Mann thinks
that Bonfire Night
is superior to
Halloween due to
its lack of hype and fanfare. Are you a fan of gunpowder, treason and plot or spooky and scary?
Halloween has really taken
off, hasn’t it? When I was a
sprog, October 31 delivered little
more than a carved pumpkin, a
Simpsons special, and a speech from the headmistress extolling the hazards
of strangers bearing sweeties. But these
days? Themed products line the shelves,
decorations adorn the high street, and TK
Maxx has been flogging orange tat since
July (“It’s Goth Christmas!” my punky friend
explains to me).
Kids now love Halloween
My kids, having come of age alongside
pumpkin spice lattes and "spooky" scented
candles, expect to go trick-or-treating on
the night, and to enjoy a packed week of
anticipatory build-up over autumn half-
term.
That includes our annual excursion to
a pumpkin-picking patch we’ve discovered,
replete with Dracula-themed adventure
playground and promenading "bubble witch"
(plaudits to the enterprising farmer who first
turned his land over for this event—
what impresses me most is the
Instagram-baiting field of sunflowers
he leaves to rot and die, so they look
as bleak and Tim Burton-esque as
absolutely possible).
Bonfire Night left behind?
But where does all this freaky
festivity leave poor old Guy Fawkes?
Bonfire Night on November 5
appears to have trended in the
opposite direction to Halloween:
my family hardly seem to notice
it’s happening until we’re halfway up the dirt-path to the organised fireworks display, trudging through the mud with our head-torches on.
"When Halloween's underworld flirtation gives kids a frisson, why does the real danger of Bonfire Night hold such little appeal?"
I’ll grant you, the anniversary itself—celebrating the torture and death of a wannabe terrorist, driven to attempted mass murder after his religion was repressed into submission by the state is... slightly old-fashioned. But I don’t understand why, when Halloween’s mild flirtation with the underworld has the power to give modern-day children such a titillating frisson, the very real danger of having their fingers burned off by sparklers seems to hold such little appeal.
Childhood memories of Bonfire Night
I mean, I’ve had genuinely terrifying experiences on Bonfire Nights. Like that year a skyrocket launched horizontally at the crowd during my secondary school’s
display, setting alight one hapless
dad’s hat.
Or the time my father
set fire to our fence, attempting to
commandeer a cut-price Catherine
wheel as we chewed on incinerated
marshmallows. Or the year I lived
in a London tower block, and some
lads took to the roof and chucked
firecrackers at pedestrians (which, to
be fair, Guy Fawkes would probably
have appreciated).
Bonfire Night is better
But here’s the thing: I’d argue that an under-the-radar, less
fervent build-up to Bonfire Night
actually makes the event much
more enjoyable. Because, however
diffident the child, however cold
the night, however stingy the local
council, big bangy bursts of colour
lighting up the sky are, you know:
impressive. Beautiful, even.
"I'd argue that a less fervent build-up to Bonfire Night makes it more enjoyable "
And at
a time when virtually all forms of
mass entertainment have dwindled
in popularity to such an extent that
I can say, with almost certainty, that
you and I are not reading the same
books, watching the same films or
listening to the same records, how
refreshing it is to share a spectacle
that can still command everyone’s
attention, offer a distinct sense of
time and place, and that forces us
to put our smartphones down (or,
at least, switch the camera away
from selfie mode, and towards
the extraordinary event actually
happening in front of us).
Sitges fireworks surprise
Fireworks are infinitely more
pleasurable when there’s no hype
or build-up beforehand. I know
this first-hand because, back in the
summer, I happened to chance upon
a firework display, instead of booking
it, queueing for it, and standing in
the rain waiting for it to happen—and it was the best I’ve ever seen.
We were in Sitges, just down
the coast from Barcelona, staying
in an apartment that we’d chosen
because it had an expansive balcony.
Unbeknownst to us, we happened
to have timed our visit to coincide
with the Festa Major given in
honour of Saint Bartholomew—the
region’s largest, and most riotous,
festival. Down on the streets (as we
discovered on subsequent nights
of our holiday) there was vibrant
folk music; giant papier-mâché
figures parading through alleyways;
traditional Catalan costumes; and
religious ceremonies. But, that first
night of our holiday, relaxing on the
balcony with a bottle of wine, we
couldn’t see any of that. All we could
see were the fireworks.
"It was the most thrilling pyrotechnic blowout of my life, and all the better for being an utter surprise"
They started at 11pm, and lasted
for around an hour. It was the most
thrilling pyrotechnic blowout of my
life, and all the better for being an
utter surprise. Out on the beaches,
no doubt, the bustling crowd
was thronging and dancing and
snogging and having a wonderful
time. But, up on our balcony, the
scale of the display could be more
properly appreciated; the stunning
synchronised explosions absolutely
knocking me for six. I knew, as I
knocked back the last of the Pinot
Grigio, that I would remember
that vista forever, as much for its
serendipity as its spectacle.
Under the radar keeps November 5 special
I’m not too bothered that my kids
have entirely forgotten what happens
on November 5. An unplanned,
unanticipated Bonfire Night still has
the capacity to blow their socks off.
And sure, Halloween is fun, with its
playful spells and potions and tricks.
But lighting up the night with colour,
noise and wonder? Now that’s what I
call magic.
Keep up with the top stories from Reader's Digest by subscribing to our weekly newsletter